Universal Pickup: the come-back

In the last days, there's been a discussion going on about the feasibility on the universal pickup idea I posted a couple of years ago (check the comments), with a key contribution of reader Ben Wa, who  also sent me this message - with sketches.

Hi Bertram! 

Attached are three sketches.  They are more based on pickup positioning ideas than anything else.  The ideas are very rough brainstorming, and the sketches are sometimes intended to be transparent views.   

The first is a quick drawing showing what amounts to two Strat pickups in the bridge and neck positions, and the crossed config of individual string pickups.  This was just an initial idea.  The crossed pickups would amount to a Strat-type magnet with a sewing machine bobbin used as a coil form.  They could be held in place with a grommet.  I know, this is pretty crude but it was just an initial idea.   

The second sketch is a tad more involved and takes a bit more explaining.  I was considering using a staple-shaped magnet that was held in place by a brass screw and a spring to allow for pole piece adjustment.  The coils would have been separate coil forms that would be sandwiched between two pieces of plastic or fiberboard.  The design would allow for humbucking configuration.  The coils wouldn't have very many turns, and would require some kind of electronic boost. I was considering using the same setup for the crossed pickups, or possibly combining an oddball mix between a single cylindrical pole and a blade piece (obviously with a magnet underneath the top plate) forming the center pickup *and* the pole for the crossed pickup. 

Long story short, I figured this would end up being impractical. Wiring harness, electronics, etc. would have been difficult if not impossible to fit in the designated space, and the potential for on-stage failure greatly increased.  A guy like Seymour Duncan or Don Lace might be able to refine it and make it practical, but I am not nearly as knowledgeable as those guys.  This was a pie-in-the-sky idea.   

The third sketch is the compromise I was talking about, and could end up being very workable.  The pickups are split amongst three strings each, and there is enough of a spread between poles to allow for a reasonable number of coil turns so active electronics won't be required.  The configuration allows for a hum-cancelling config in certain combinations as well.  I showed direct magnets in my sketch at the neck and bridge, but there is nothing that says there can't be a kind of interrupted blade pole (shaped sort of like the side shields you see on a Fender Jaguar, only cut deeper).  If you really don't want the neck/bridge sections, they could be eliminated and the space used to stretch out the "X".  I only went with what I have here because I felt it gave a greater number of combinations.  

The third sketch, I feel, is the best compromise for the idea that I have come up with so far.  I feel it will give a pretty good usable number of combinations.  The part I need to know from you is more about how you envision the switching functions.  I feel it is critical to rig the switching to something that makes sense to you - the end-user.   

One thing that I have not shown:  I would like to see the addition of a piezoelectric pickup into the aluminum box near the neck joint.  This would allow adding in more sound of the wood.  Frank Zappa did this many decades ago, and he claimed it worked well for him.  

Again, these are all just rough initial ideas.  Any thoughts are welcome.  Keep in mind that for a magnetic pickup to work, you need a magnetic field source and a coil of wire with enough turns to generate the output level you require.  After that, almost anything is possible.   

Note that the actual pickup poles could be shrouded with a plastic cover plate over the aluminum box top, giving the overall appearance much closer to what you have sketched out in your design.  As long as the cover material is non-ferrous, it will be invisible to the magnetic field.   

Hope you enjoy, 

Ben 

 Thank you Ben, let's pursue the thread under this post - and any comment is welcome.